Disagreement: Stage-Setting and Kornblith’s Skepticism

Suppose David and Nates disagree about the morality of Capital Punishment.  David thinks that CP is unjustifiable, whereas Nates--ever the Kantian--thinks that CP may under certain circumstances be not only justified but morally required.  David and Nates are aware of their disagreement with each other--they're facing off in the seminar room.  Now consider this question: … Continue reading Disagreement: Stage-Setting and Kornblith’s Skepticism